Well-Oiled  
For Marine Engineers

Facts and comments about engines, their lubrication and efficient running of ship.

Spectrometry

Spectrographic measurements of the luboil determine its metal composition. The presence of certain elements can uniquely identify additives and contaminants in the luboil, the type of any contamination and the condition of machinery.

For example, Aluminium is a general indicator of wear from Aluminium piston skirts, with a typical value below 10 ppm. Levels may rise if a piston has been replaced in an engine. In an engine oil it may indicate the presence of catalytic fines present in the fuel oil.

To receive your FREE copy of the "Metals - Originating source" guide, email us at

The significance of Viscosity Index (VI)

For luboils, oil viscosity decreases as temperature increases. Lubricants subjected to a wide range of operating and ambient temperatures require a lubricant that exhibits minimum relative change on its viscosity with broad variations in temperature. For luboils with similar kinematic viscosity, the higher the VI, the smaller the effect of temperature on its viscosity.

To better understand VI, we need to review how it was developed many years ago:

  • VI is a means of classifying the viscosity vs. temperature behaviour of luboils, on the basis of two reference luboils selected to represent two extremes of behaviour:
  • The reference oil for high (H) VI was assigned a VI of 100. The oil used was a paraffinic base oil from Pennsylvania crude oil, which many years ago were considered to display the best viscosity vs. temperature characteristics.
  • The reference oil for Low (L) VI was assigned a VI of 0 and was a naphthenic base oil from the coastal region of Gulf of Mexico, which showed a very poor viscosity vs. temperature relationship.

Using this simple approach, lubricants that exhibit less change in viscosity (with respect to temperature) than the reference oil H, will have a VI greater than 100. Most synthetic oils would be in that category. Lubricants having viscosity change (with respect to temperature) greater than the reference oil L, will have a negative VI.

In terms of lubrication, the most important property to ensure optimum oil film strength (at the point of contact between the two metal surfaces) is the actual viscosity of the luboil.

As temperature increases, a synthetic luboil would be more viscous, better able to maintain oil film thickness and thus more able to (relatively) reduce component wear. Hot running systems such as Compressors, gearboxes and turbochargers, are likely to benefit from such high VI synthetic luboils.

As temperature decreases below zero, a mineral luboil would become too viscous, to the point where it cannot be pumped or flow to the area requiring lubrication. This would result in poor lubrication or even system starvation of sufficient luboil to prevent metal-to-metal contact, which would lead to increased wear. Critical deck equipment operating under extremely low temperatures or wide temperature variations, would benefit from the wider operating temperature range of synthetic luboils.

Hints and Tips

Before filling grease into a new grease gun, consider disassembling the gun and cleaning it thoroughly, as it is likely that metal shavings may be found in new grease guns. The metal shavings may be present from the manufacturing process of the grease gun.
A better balanced engine saves fuel

Cylinder pressure is the most important parameter for describing the operating condition of a diesel engine. There are many diagnostic tools that optimise the performance of diesel engines, from mechanical to portable electronic ones and to continuous online monitoring of cylinder pressure readily integrated into the ship's overall automation system.

Late or retarded fuel injection, can account for up to 2% of fuel wastage per degree of late injection.

Owners can reduce their fuel oil bill, by considering the following factors :

  • More efficient timing combustion
  • More efficient cooling
  • Optimising blended ratio performance

Engines that are timed according to OEM engine manual or testbed data use theoretical settings, which may not correspond to the ideal injection setting of the engine in service. It is also likely that the timing tolerances would vary, as the engine experiences normal wear and tear while in service. Precise information enabling the engineer to regularly adjust the fuel system to optimise cylinder performance, would be an important contributor to reducing the fuel oil bill.

In addition, accurate measurements of cylinder pressure and subsequent trend analysis will indicate early warning signals of deteriorating cylinder performance. Such trend analysis will help identify onset of wear in piston rings, fuel injectors, exhaust valves, fuel pumps, etc.

A portable pressure meter that can help engineers reduce costs, by adjusting engine tuning to the lowest fuel consumption, and getting early warning of faults and onset of wear, may be of use to you. To receive further product details and examples of comparing a whole set of engine cylinders, and graphical analysis of CP and PV diagrams, email us at

 

If you liked Well-Oiled, please forward it to a friend or colleague

If you are reading a copy sent to you by someone else, you can get your own subscription by emailing us at